Similar, But Different
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Updated: 2:15 AM Sep 30, 2008
Similar, But Different
Many are making comparisons from today's economic crisis to that of the Great Depression, but historians say that's too much of a stretch.
Posted: 10:46 PM Sep 29, 2008
Reporter: Jamie Edmonds
Email Address: jamie.edmonds@wilx.com
width:179 and height: 119 and picwidth: 179 and pciheight: 119
The Wall St. street sign is photographed in front of the American flag hanging on the New York Stock Exchange prior to a NYC Central Labor Council rally for worker protections, Thursday, Sept. 25, 2008 in New York. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer)
Font Size:

Slumping stocks, a melting housing market, wall street in peril. It's no wonder some think history may be repeating itself.

"The main reason the comparison is made is that the stock market crash in 1929 was the first loud exclamation something was wrong," Mark Kornbluh said.

Kornbluh is the chair of the History Department at MSU. He said there are similarities between today and the Great Depression.

"The economy really ground to a halt and the first signs were a financial collapse in the stock market and it spiraled down," Kornbluh said.

But nothing, he said, compares to the scale of that economic crisis.

In the late twenties and thirties lines for bread reached around city blocks, thousands were out work and thousands more lost their homes and were forced to live in shacks.

"There were people selling apples on the street for 10 cents to support themselves," Kornbluh said.

The biggest difference Kornbluh said is federal intervention. Back then the government didn't intervene until years later when the country had a new president and a new deal.

"The difference is it took three years for any response," he said. "Political leaders are trying to respond here in three weeks instead of three years."

The economic future is still unknown, but Kornbluh said he hopes we've all learned from the past.


Current Weather Conditions