Similar, But Different
Save Email Print
Updated: 2:15 AM Sep 30, 2008
Similar, But Different
Many are making comparisons from today's economic crisis to that of the Great Depression, but historians say that's too much of a stretch.
Posted: 10:46 PM Sep 29, 2008
Reporter: Jamie Edmonds
Email Address: jamie.edmonds@wilx.com
Font Size:

Slumping stocks, a melting housing market, wall street in peril. It's no wonder some think history may be repeating itself.

"The main reason the comparison is made is that the stock market crash in 1929 was the first loud exclamation something was wrong," Mark Kornbluh said.

Kornbluh is the chair of the History Department at MSU. He said there are similarities between today and the Great Depression.

"The economy really ground to a halt and the first signs were a financial collapse in the stock market and it spiraled down," Kornbluh said.

But nothing, he said, compares to the scale of that economic crisis.

In the late twenties and thirties lines for bread reached around city blocks, thousands were out work and thousands more lost their homes and were forced to live in shacks.

"There were people selling apples on the street for 10 cents to support themselves," Kornbluh said.

The biggest difference Kornbluh said is federal intervention. Back then the government didn't intervene until years later when the country had a new president and a new deal.

"The difference is it took three years for any response," he said. "Political leaders are trying to respond here in three weeks instead of three years."

The economic future is still unknown, but Kornbluh said he hopes we've all learned from the past.


WILX Poll
Should Police Be Allowed To Use Tasers On Suspects?

Yes
No


Police Investigate Shooting at Lansing Night Spot
Police Investigate Shooting at Lansing Night Spot
  • Posted By: Sandii have spent my share of time going to the bars, however, the Venue is a crime not a bar. They were supose to hire additional security. With all the unemployment why didn't they have at least 2 or 3 guys out there patroling the parking lot at 2 a.m.? They know exactly what their patrons are like. They should have had patrols outside weeks ago. I think the Venue should be closed down, and I like the idea of a good samaritan law,if you see a crime and don't report it, you can go to jail. Lots of people had their pictures on the video lately. Anyone who goes to a bar like the Venue and thinks even one fight in the parking lot is OK has a problem, and should stay away from the bars. This constant fighting is outragous. What are we waiting for? Someone to be killed?
  • Posted By: The city can pass a good samaritan law in which a person can serve two days in jail for not reporting a crime. It might scare some of these people into witnessing.
  • Posted By: sick and tiredput em back on the boat
  • Posted By: LegallyRadBetween venue and x-cel the cops are driving like a tennis match from north to south. Everytime there is an incident at a hip-hop club they should have to serve 3 weekends playing nothing but classic rock, country and bluegrass.
  • Posted By: GusDoesn't surprise me that the Lansing Police couldnt find a suspect or a victim without some outside help. With the leadership that they have with Virg "Little Man" Bernero and Mark "I am an IDIOT" Alley, it is a wonder that they can find their car keys. As for the VENUE, the violence at that location hasn't changed since the city shut down the last night club that was there. Great job Lansing!
  • Posted By: concernedThey need to shut down the Venue. Obviously the crowd that is drawn to the Venue is the same that use to frequent the Temple CLub and the LA globe. Unfortunately people do not know how to act and trouble follows these type of establishments. It is waste of resources. SHUT IT DOWN
  • Posted By: ChrisI've been to probably close to 100 heavy metal concerts and clubs/events over the years, never a shooting. Their is a completely different mind set with this Venue crowd and the mentality and music it supports.
  • Posted By: Concerned CitizenThis is the 3rd shooting at this club since it opened earlier this year. Since South Lansing and Holt is not known for this type of behavior, I can only surmise that the people that frequent this establishment are the problem. I think the time has come to close this place down and keep these hoodlums out out of our community!
  • Posted By: Frustrated!!!I have been a patron of the Venue since it first opened and the "stories" that the MEDIA is hyping up is just that STORIES!!!! Readers need to learn to differentiate the facts from myths...I also attended the party this past saturday night and there were not "several" fights as the NEWS 10 has advised us!!! Heck they weren't even there, but I guess you gotta keep your job somehow!!! I am so so tired of the media making a mountain out of a molehill...and furthermore, from what we could see the perpetrator was directly in front of the police...so you do the math!!! It appears to me that the Venue security do their job to get the patrons out safely, and then it would also appear to me that the police department would attempt to be "proactive" opposed to "reactive"...I have witnessed them sit across the street at Lowe's and do "absolutely nothing" to assist the Venue security when "occurences" do happen in the parking lot of Mark Realty...not the parking lot of the Venue Live!!!!
  • Posted By: TracyHow much violent crime has to happen at this club in order to shut it down? I understand it's someone's business and source of income, but come on... there's got to be some responsibility taken by the owner to protect the public and law-abiding patrons. I'm sure the owner is aware of the riff-raff coming in; use your right as the owner to deny service.
WILX Special Section
Stock Quotes
Real Time Stock Quotes.
Reinventing GM
Follow GM's Progress
WILX Pet-Pals
Find Your Companion Adopt A Pet
FinditLansing.com
From Clothes To Appliances Buy or Sell It
Relay For Life
Find Relays In Your Area
DTV Information
Need Help With Digital Television?
Interactive Weather Map
Get Your Weather Where Ever When Ever
Lansing's History
Find Out What Happened This Week in History.
Sponsored Headlines
AP Videos